Home

Advertisement

Previous Entry | Next Entry

x-posted to parenting101 community

  • Jan. 24th, 2008 at 7:41 PM
uncle
I just finished watching part 7 of the 7-part PBS Special on Evolution. Parts 1-6 were probably one of the best things I've watched in a long time. However, part 7 was an altogether different experience. It was titled: "What about God?".
Now, it's not that it was of a lesser quality than the other 6, it's just, well... The range of emotions I experienced went from Disbelief, Shame, Pity, Surprise, Anger, Fear, and Exasperation, with a few stops in between. It had never before been so clear to me the precise nightmare that our society is in today.

At different points in the show, there were scenes that depicted rooms full of young children and their parents signing along to a song that went something like: "I don't believe in evolution | I know creation's true", and "God created everything | and the 6 day story's true | so the Big Bang theory's just a dud | and the million years are, too". Another scene showed someone - apparently one of the 'leading activists against the lie of evolution', explaining how the flood (Noah's ark) deposited animals around the world in such a way that they were buried in mud and created fossils, only a couple thousand of years ago, with cute little diagrams too. There was a large section of the show devoted to talking about this school in Tennessee, where a group of students started a petition to get "Scientific Creation" taught in their Science Class, simultaneously with the theory of evolutionary biology. Thankfully, they didn't succeed, but they kept showing scenes of this group of students sitting around talking about how evolution is inferior to their beliefs - and frankly, much of what they said to support their "Scientific Creation" was disturbingly inaccurate...

My fear is that, in a couple of years, my Daughter is going to be starting school (okay, she's 6 months now, so it might be a while...), but there seems to be a growing number of these 'movements' and petitions to either force evolution out of school, or throw in these other things like Intelligent Design, or whatever "Scientific Creation" is supposed to be (from what I could gather, because the schools have said that they would allow any valid, scientific theory to be taught alongside evolution in science classes, Christians and other religious people have been trying to come up with some type of scientific version of the creation story that's in the bible... which essentially means they take small pieces of science that agrees with their views and throw away the rest to come up with something that does not stand up to any type of scientific testing, and try to pass it off as a theory that is just as valid as evolution).

It worries me that when she should be learning about science, and biology, and the natural world, it's either going to be completely absent from her curriculum, or, she's going to also have her head filled with this magical, feel-good, 'God loves you', nonsense, and be completely screwed when she has to think for herself on the matter.

IF they, for some reason, decide that the Christian - or any other - view of creationism should be taught in school, they should only do it in a separate, theology class, or something that has a clear distinction from "Science" vs "made up crap", and I really don't think that they should have any class where religion is the focus of study, outside of college curriculum.

Anyway, I apologize for this getting to be longer and more rant-y than I intended... I'm still kind of fuming thinking about this stuff... What I was hoping to find out is this: What steps can I start taking - and when - to help ensure that when my Daughter is in school, somewhere along the line, she is able to learn about evolution, and other science. I'm not qualified to teach it to her. Having her watch the PBS special(s) over and over is not going to help her learn about it... so where do I turn?
  • 4 comments
  • Leave a comment
  • Add to Memories
  • Share this!
  • Link

Comments

( 4 comments — Leave a comment )
[info]velcrobandit wrote:
Jan. 25th, 2008 02:06 am (UTC)
Dude, you are so behind the times. Have you not heard of the greatest church ever, the church of The Flying Spaghetti Monster???
[info]seifertim wrote:
Jan. 25th, 2008 03:07 am (UTC)
Of course! I have the logo on our *older* car ;)
[info]stryder619 wrote:
Jan. 25th, 2008 11:28 pm (UTC)
I wonders... Have you seen Jesus Camp? If not, watch it. now. That'll scare you for real.
[info]zaxec wrote:
Jan. 29th, 2008 05:22 pm (UTC)
two things:
1. It is good for your to take it upon yourself to expose her to stuff outside of school. This is very important for children. Plenty of the things that we learn when we are young come from us reading about things we are interested in, and not from school. I propose that you either familiarize yourself with children's books on evolution(possibly research on Amazon) or read a few books to get yourself to a point where you are comfortable answering a child's questions about the origins of life. You already know a LOT(I remember in middle school, you made a reference to blue-green algae that got me to look up what that was all about, I'd never heard of it). If you have any specific questions, you (or you and she together) can always ask the internet. Spending time with the kid will ensure that the things which impacts her most will not be whatever they happen to teach in school, but her ability to find answers for herself.

and 2. I should point out that while I happen to ascribe to the theory of macroevolution, it is my understanding that no examples of evolution producing a new species have been found, and, as they said in south park, the theory of evolution is "full of holes". It's tricky stuff, especially with the philosophical implications, but probably worth researching if you truly care and have the time.
( 4 comments — Leave a comment )